| No Matter What Nigel Wright, Simon Franglen, Friðrik Karlsson | Nigel Wright, Simon Franglen, Friðrik Karlsson | - | - | 4:34 |
| I Don’t Know How to Love Him Nigel Wright, Jessie Montgomery, Sara Bareilles | Nigel Wright, Jessie Montgomery, Sara Bareilles | - | - | 3:41 |
| Gethsemane (I Only Wanted to Say) Nigel Wright, Jessie Montgomery | Nigel Wright, Jessie Montgomery | - | - | 5:44 |
| Superstar Nigel Wright, Jessie Montgomery | Nigel Wright, Jessie Montgomery | - | - | 4:34 |
| Everything’s Alright (reprise) Nigel Wright, Jessie Montgomery, Sara Bareilles | Nigel Wright, Jessie Montgomery, Sara Bareilles | - | - | 0:40 |
| Damned for All Time / Blood Money Nigel Wright, Jessie Montgomery | Nigel Wright, Jessie Montgomery | - | - | 4:33 |
| The Last Supper Nigel Wright, Jessie Montgomery | Nigel Wright, Jessie Montgomery | - | - | 7:10 |
| The Arrest Nigel Wright, Jessie Montgomery | Nigel Wright, Jessie Montgomery | - | - | 4:02 |
| Peter’s Denial Nigel Wright, Jessie Montgomery, Sara Bareilles | Nigel Wright, Jessie Montgomery, Sara Bareilles | - | - | 0:38 |
| Pilate and Christ Nigel Wright, Jessie Montgomery | Nigel Wright, Jessie Montgomery | - | - | 2:58 |
| King Herod’s Song Nigel Wright, Alice Cooper, Jessie Montgomery | Nigel Wright, Alice Cooper, Jessie Montgomery | - | - | 3:22 |
| Could We Start Again, Please? Nigel Wright, Jessie Montgomery, Sara Bareilles | Nigel Wright, Jessie Montgomery, Sara Bareilles | - | - | 2:35 |
| John Nineteen Forty‐One Nigel Wright, Jessie Montgomery | Nigel Wright, Jessie Montgomery | - | - | 2:48 |
| Heaven on Their Minds Nigel Wright, Jessie Montgomery | Nigel Wright, Jessie Montgomery | - | - | 4:30 |
| What’s the Buzz / Strange Thing Mystifying Nigel Wright, Jessie Montgomery, Sara Bareilles | Nigel Wright, Jessie Montgomery, Sara Bareilles | - | - | 4:22 |
| Everything’s Alright Nigel Wright, Jessie Montgomery, Sara Bareilles | Nigel Wright, Jessie Montgomery, Sara Bareilles | - | - | 4:05 |
| This Jesus Must Die Nigel Wright, Jessie Montgomery | Nigel Wright, Jessie Montgomery | - | - | 3:36 |
| Hosanna Nigel Wright, Jessie Montgomery | Nigel Wright, Jessie Montgomery | - | - | 2:59 |
| Simon Zealotes / Poor Jerusalem Nigel Wright, Jessie Montgomery | Nigel Wright, Jessie Montgomery | - | - | 5:12 |
| Pilate’s Dream Nigel Wright, Jessie Montgomery | Nigel Wright, Jessie Montgomery | - | - | 1:48 |