| It Came Upon the Midnight Clear Eugene Ormandy, Philadelphia Orchestra | Eugene Ormandy, Philadelphia Orchestra | 2025 | - | 3:09 |
| It Came Upon a Midnight Clear Arthur Fiedler, Boston Pops | Arthur Fiedler, Boston Pops | 2023 | - | 3:04 |
| It Came Upon a Midnight Clear Luther Henderson, Eileen Farrell | Luther Henderson, Eileen Farrell | 2016 | - | 2:52 |
| It Came Upon the Midnight Clear Bob Chilcott | Bob Chilcott | 2011 | - | 2:18 |
| It Came Upon the Midnight Clear Alfred Deller | Alfred Deller | 2008 | - | 2:25 |
| O Little Town of Bethlehem / It Came Upon the Midnight Clear Charles Daellenbach, Eugene Watts, Jeff Nelsen | Charles Daellenbach, Eugene Watts, Jeff Nelsen | 2007 | - | 3:16 |
| It Came Upon the Midnight Clear BYU choirs | BYU choirs | 2007 | - | 4:35 |
| It Came Upon a Midnight Clear Eddie Higgins, George Mraz | Eddie Higgins, George Mraz | 2006 | - | 4:03 |
| It Came Upon a Midnight Clear Rick Wakeman | Rick Wakeman | 2006 | - | 5:14 |
| It Came Upon A Midnight Clear Antti Sarpila, Johanna Iivanainen, Pentti Lasanen | Antti Sarpila, Johanna Iivanainen, Pentti Lasanen | 2003 | - | 3:09 |
| It Came Upon a Midnight Clear Eileen Farrell | Eileen Farrell | 2002 | - | 2:55 |
| It Came Upon the Midnight Clear Francis Jackson | Francis Jackson | 2000 | - | 3:31 |
| It Came Upon the Midnight Clear Martin Neary | Martin Neary | 1999 | - | 3:10 |
| Pār mazo ciemu ielejā Aleksandrs Viļumanis, Latvian National Symphony Orchestra | Aleksandrs Viļumanis, Latvian National Symphony Orchestra | 1999 | - | 2:00 |
| It Came Upon a Midnight Clear Marty Gold, Sergio Franchi | Marty Gold, Sergio Franchi | 1999 | - | 2:38 |
| It Came Upon a Midnight Clear Peter Knight | Peter Knight | 1998 | - | 2:36 |
| It Came Upon a Midnight Clear Jameson Marvin | Jameson Marvin | 1998 | - | 1:26 |
| It Came Upon a Midnight Clear Virgil Fox | Virgil Fox | 1997 | - | 3:34 |
| It Came Upon a Midnight Clear Kitarō | Kitarō | 1996 | - | 4:00 |
| It Came Upon the Midnight Clear Philip Brunelle | Philip Brunelle | 1995 | - | 3:22 |