| On the Willows Stephen Schwartz | Stephen Schwartz | - | - | 3:07 |
| Forgiveness’ Embrace Stephen Schwartz | Stephen Schwartz | - | - | 4:20 |
| Lucky / Wondrous Things Stephen Schwartz | Stephen Schwartz | - | - | 5:41 |
| Making Good Stephen Schwartz | Stephen Schwartz | - | - | 4:00 |
| Crowded Island Stephen Schwartz | Stephen Schwartz | - | - | 3:22 |
| Prepare Ye the Way of the Lord Stephen Schwartz | Stephen Schwartz | - | - | 2:03 |
| Save the People Stephen Schwartz | Stephen Schwartz | - | - | 3:25 |
| Learn Your Lessons Well Stephen Schwartz | Stephen Schwartz | - | - | 1:26 |
| Bless the Lord Stephen Schwartz | Stephen Schwartz | - | - | 3:02 |
| All for the Best Stephen Schwartz | Stephen Schwartz | - | - | 2:32 |
| All Good Gifts Stephen Schwartz | Stephen Schwartz | - | - | 3:34 |
| Light of the World Stephen Schwartz | Stephen Schwartz | - | - | 2:59 |
| Turn Back, O Man Stephen Schwartz | Stephen Schwartz | - | - | 4:21 |
| Alas for You Stephen Schwartz | Stephen Schwartz | - | - | 2:01 |
| We Beseech Thee Stephen Schwartz | Stephen Schwartz | - | - | 3:37 |
| Finale Stephen Schwartz | Stephen Schwartz | - | - | 5:41 |
| Day by Day (reprise) Stephen Schwartz | Stephen Schwartz | - | - | 1:56 |
| Day by Day Stephen Schwartz | Stephen Schwartz | - | - | 3:16 |
| Defying Gravity Stephen Schwartz | Stephen Schwartz | - | - | 3:58 |