| O Holy Night Paul Jackson, Jr., Rickey Minor, Sy Smith | Paul Jackson, Jr., Rickey Minor, Sy Smith | 2014 | - | 5:08 |
| Medley: O Come All Ye Faithful / Angels We Have Heard on High / Hark! The Herald Angels Sing Paul Jackson, Jr., Rickey Minor | Paul Jackson, Jr., Rickey Minor | 2014 | - | 4:14 |
| Hark! The Herald Angels Sing Nathan East, Paul Jackson, Jr., Ricky Lawson | Nathan East, Paul Jackson, Jr., Ricky Lawson | 2008 | - | 5:24 |
| Ave Maria Nathan East, Paul Jackson, Jr., Ricky Lawson | Nathan East, Paul Jackson, Jr., Ricky Lawson | 2008 | - | 4:57 |
| Joy to the World Eric Darius, Paul Jackson, Jr. | Eric Darius, Paul Jackson, Jr. | 2006 | - | 5:00 |
| Jesus Loves Me Paul Jackson, Jr. | Paul Jackson, Jr. | 1992 | - | 5:12 |
| The Wizard and I Alex Budman, Paul Jackson, Jr. | Alex Budman, Paul Jackson, Jr. | - | - | 5:53 |
| What Is This Feeling? / Dear Old Shiz Alex Budman, Paul Jackson, Jr. | Alex Budman, Paul Jackson, Jr. | - | - | 4:22 |
| Popular Alex Budman, Paul Jackson, Jr. | Alex Budman, Paul Jackson, Jr. | - | - | 5:55 |
| Overture / No One Mourns the Wicked Alex Budman, Paul Jackson, Jr. | Alex Budman, Paul Jackson, Jr. | - | - | 6:55 |
| Dancing Through Life Alex Budman, Paul Jackson, Jr. | Alex Budman, Paul Jackson, Jr. | - | - | 5:58 |
| Thank Goodness Alex Budman, Paul Jackson, Jr. | Alex Budman, Paul Jackson, Jr. | - | - | 4:01 |
| Defying Gravity Alex Budman, Paul Jackson, Jr. | Alex Budman, Paul Jackson, Jr. | - | - | 3:44 |
| For Good Gavin Greenaway, Alex Budman, Paul Jackson, Jr. | Gavin Greenaway, Alex Budman, Paul Jackson, Jr. | - | - | 4:32 |
| O’ Come All Ye Faithful Marcus Miller, Ivan Hampden, Jr., John Clayton | Marcus Miller, Ivan Hampden, Jr., John Clayton | - | - | 4:19 |
| Silent Night Nathan East, Paul Jackson, Jr. | Nathan East, Paul Jackson, Jr. | - | - | 4:30 |