| Wishing You Were Somehow Here Again David Cullen, Peter Manning, Emmy Rossum | David Cullen, Peter Manning, Emmy Rossum | - | - | 3:41 |
| The Music of the Night David Cullen, Peter Manning | David Cullen, Peter Manning | - | - | 5:39 |
| Learn to Be Lonely David Cullen, Peter Manning, Minnie Driver | David Cullen, Peter Manning, Minnie Driver | - | - | 2:21 |
| Think of Me David Cullen, Peter Manning, Emmy Rossum | David Cullen, Peter Manning, Emmy Rossum | - | - | 3:41 |
| The Point of No Return David Cullen, Peter Manning, Emmy Rossum | David Cullen, Peter Manning, Emmy Rossum | - | - | 8:01 |
| All I Ask of You David Cullen, Peter Manning, Emmy Rossum | David Cullen, Peter Manning, Emmy Rossum | - | - | 4:52 |
| All I Ask of You (reprise) David Cullen, Peter Manning, Emmy Rossum | David Cullen, Peter Manning, Emmy Rossum | - | - | 2:16 |
| The Phantom of the Opera David Cullen, Peter Manning, Emmy Rossum | David Cullen, Peter Manning, Emmy Rossum | - | - | 3:36 |
| The Mirror (Angel of Music) David Cullen, Peter Manning, Emmy Rossum | David Cullen, Peter Manning, Emmy Rossum | - | - | 1:59 |
| Don't Cry for Me Argentina Barry Wordsworth, David Cullen, Julian Lloyd Webber | Barry Wordsworth, David Cullen, Julian Lloyd Webber | - | - | 4:37 |
| Love Changes Everything Barry Wordsworth, David Cullen, Julian Lloyd Webber | Barry Wordsworth, David Cullen, Julian Lloyd Webber | - | - | 3:02 |
| Down Once More / Track Down This Murderer David Cullen, Peter Manning, Emmy Rossum | David Cullen, Peter Manning, Emmy Rossum | - | - | 12:49 |
| Starlight Express Barry Wordsworth, David Cullen, Julian Lloyd Webber | Barry Wordsworth, David Cullen, Julian Lloyd Webber | - | - | 3:03 |
| The Phantom of the Opera Barry Wordsworth, David Cullen, Julian Lloyd Webber | Barry Wordsworth, David Cullen, Julian Lloyd Webber | - | - | 2:48 |
| Prima Donna David Cullen, Nigel Wright, Peter Manning | David Cullen, Nigel Wright, Peter Manning | - | - | 3:30 |
| Masquerade David Cullen, Peter Manning | David Cullen, Peter Manning | - | - | 5:32 |
| Angel of Music David Cullen, Peter Manning, Emmy Rossum | David Cullen, Peter Manning, Emmy Rossum | - | - | 2:44 |
| Overture David Cullen, Peter Manning | David Cullen, Peter Manning | - | - | 2:47 |